Unified Rules of Mixed Martial Arts Revised

As reported in an excellent piece by MMAJunkie.com, the Association of Boxing Commissions has adopted revisions to the Unified Rules of Mixed Martial Arts.  The change that has gotten the most press is an amendment to the "no strikes to the back of the head" rule taking some aspects of the "mohawk" rule (no strikes along the center line of the head running towards the spine) and the "headphones" rule (no strikes at any location that would be behind a pair of headphones worn on the head).  The new rule uses the mohawk interpretation towards the top of the head but then widens the prohibited striking area towards the base of the neck. 

Another rule change is the prohibition of "12 to 6" elbow strikes (striking downward with the point of the elbow).  This is a reversal from changes the ABC made to the Uniform Rules of MMA in 2008 when it acted to eliminate the restriction against such a move.

Although ABC's MMA committee hopes that the revisions to the Uniform Rules will be adopted, well, uniformly, state athletic commissions are free to reject any or all of them.  For example, although the ABC changed the breakdown of weight classes in 2008, most commissions (and the UFC) kept the MMA light heavyweight class at the traditional 186 to 205 pounds.  

One thing that makes universal adoption more likely than in the past is that the rules changes were created by  the ABC committee on MMA rather than the ABC itself.   The MMA committee, which was adopted in 2008, largely in response to complaints about the proposed new weight classes, counts as its members the directors of many of the most influential state athletic commissions.

It would greatly benefit the sport of MMA for all states to adopt the modified rules.  Even if a particular commission disagrees with a particular rule change, having a common rule set makes it easier for fans to understand what is happening, it makes it easier for officials to oversee matches, and it makes it safer for the fighters.   

State Athletic Commission Websites

Editor's Note: This post was originally written in August 2009, but is periodically updated as additional states pass mixed martial arts regulations.

This post will link to all of the State Athletic Commissions which regulate Mixed Martial Arts events (or which would regulate them upon legalization in that state).  State MMA regulations are changing regularly, so you should not rely exclusively on this list--or even the athletic commission's website--in determining whether MMA is legal or what rules to follow.  As just two examples, both Alabama and South Dakota signed bills creating boxing commissions in 2009.  The best bet is to contact the licensing authority directly to confirm what is allowed and whether the posted rules are current.

43 states officially sanction Mixed Martial Arts.  The holdouts are Alabama, Alaska, Connecticut, New York, Vermont, West Virginia, and Wyoming.

ALABAMA 

MMA is not sanctioned, but it appears to be legal if sanctioned by the International Sport Combat Federation.)

ALASKA (No Commission)

ARIZONA

ARKANSAS

CALIFORNIA (amateur events illegal)

COLORADO (amateur events illegal)

CONNECTICUT (mixed martial arts is illegal)

FLORIDA (amateur events illegal)

GEORGIA

HAWAII

IDAHO

ILLINOIS

INDIANA

IOWA

KANSAS

KENTUCKY

LOUISIANA

MAINE (Legalized Mixed Martial Arts as of September 12, 2009.   Maine dissolved its athletic commission in 2007, so MMA will be overseen by a 5-member "Mixed Martial Arts Authority" appointed by the Governor.)

MARYLAND

MASSACHUSETTS

MICHIGAN (pro events illegal)

MINNESOTA

MISSISSIPPI

MISSOURI

MONTANA

NEBRASKA

NEVADA

NEW HAMPSHIRE

NEW JERSEY

NEW MEXICO

NEW YORK (amateur and pro events illegal, but it's only a matter of time)

NORTH CAROLINA

NORTH DAKOTA

OHIO

OKLAHOMA

OREGON

PENNSYLVANIA

RHODE ISLAND  A bill regulating MMA was passed and transmitted to the Governor on November 4, 2009.   The Governor did not act and the bill became law without his signature on November 12, 2009

SOUTH CAROLINA 

SOUTH DAKOTA (No website, but on March 30, 2009, Governor M. Michael Rounds signed into law a bill creating the South Dakota Boxing Commission to oversee boxing and MMA)

TENNESSEE

TEXAS

UTAH

VERMONT

VIRGINIA

WASHINGTON

WASHINGTON, DC (amateur events limited)

WEST VIRGINIA

WISCONSIN

WYOMING (No Commission)

As always, if you are aware of any additions or changes that should be made to this list, please email me and let me know.  Thanks.

What is "Mixed Martial Arts Law?"

Since this blog launched, a lot of people have asked: "What is Mixed Martial Arts Law?"  The real answer is that any law can affect a mixed martial artist or MMA promoter (as loyal readers to this blog can attest).  That said, a more precise definition is: "the collection of statutes, administrative rules, and regulations that govern mixed martial arts competitions." 

Many people don't realize that, on the flipside, some mixed martial arts contests do not have to comply with any MMA-specific laws.  In Iowa, for example, professional MMA is explicitly allowed and is regulated by the Iowa Athletic Commissioner, but amateur MMA (unlike amateur boxing) is not under the purview of the Commissioner.  Nonetheless, that aspect of mixed martial arts continues to thrive in Iowa.  

After explaining the above, I sometimes get this follow-up question: "If a state athletic commission does not oversee mixed martial arts, why aren't the fighters arrested for assault?" The answer is, typically, that the activity is consensual.  In Iowa, assault is defined by section 708.1.  After listing the activities that constitute assault, the code section provides an exception for cases where the persons engaged in the activities are:

voluntary participants in a sport, social or other activity, not in itself criminal, and such act is a reasonably foreseeable incident of such sport or activity, and does not create an unreasonable risk of serious injury or breach of the peace . . .

Without such an exception, mixed martial artists would face assault charges, but so would participants in any contact sport.